When you say "personal Trad 401" do you mean "traditional IRA" or "solo 401K?" In a Roth 401(k) vs. Roth IRA comparison, both offer tax-free growth & tax-free retirement income. The table below shows the pros and cons of both account types. Since your work match is unaffected by your contributions, I think it would be better to contribute to your traditional IRA until you max it out for the year. Thats good info - I just realized something. No such limit applies to whole life insurance premiums. So just want to make sure not doing something dumb if I were to put more money on another platform. I did not reinvest tax savings because I just learned that concept today. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. comments. Thoughts? Roth 401k Versus Traditional 401k So I originally thought it was a slam dunk to go Roth over Traditional but now I'm not so sure. You’ll pay more taxes now than you would have later in most situations. I’m putting 1.5% of my income in Roth as a just in case. So I’m pretty sure there are no income limits to contributing to a Roth 401k like there are to a Roth IRA. Roth: you now have $22500 to withdraw tax free. Roth 401k vs 401k. If you don’t know (most people really don’t), it’s also okay to split the difference 50/50 to get some benefit now and some later. I think I would stick with traditional in your situation. In 25% marginal rate that would be $23125. We’re here to help! •Have a personal Trad 401 that I opened in 2020 at Fidelity for 2019 tax refund savings. If you will pay less now through income tax than when you pull it out, then it makes sense to use a Roth. Roth 401(k) Your company may offer a Roth 401(k) in addition to a traditional 401(k) option. mpi vs roth ira reddit, So I started a Roth IRA when I was 18 or so and never put any more money into it after my initial $1,000 investment (I know, I should have). Divide that by 11 (the months left) and have that much put into your 401K per month. Well, at 100% means you won’t have any taxable income in retirement (except for any other sources like social security). Close. Great point on using this Traditional IRA to add more to it during the year. A Roth 401k will likely make you richer than a traditional 401k and is one of the best investment decisions you can make as a younger investor in your 20’s or 30’s because of the tax-free withdrawal advantages given an uncertain future. Second, unlike Sara, Sam was able to ensure that all of his savings were able to grow at the 7% rate in the retirement account. Does your employer not have a Roth 401k option? Edit: “personal Trad 401” is really a Traditional IRA. I don't even bother with my employer's anemic "matching" 401k. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. My employer matches 1.5X my Roth 401K contributions up to 6% (I've been maxing it by putting in 6%, so they give me 9%, and the two add up to 15%). TranAmerica target date fund. Based on that, if you have low income now and with the recent tax reductions assume that Roth is better and go 100% in Roth. How to do the Mega backdoor Roth at Microsoft into your personal Roth IRA. Roth IRA all the way. Should I keep roth until i make more or should i have swapped already? Traditional: you now have $30000 of taxable income to withdraw. If you withdraw less than the standard deduction it’s all tax free. Their appeal: A 401(k) plan offers a tax-advantaged way to save for retirement, making it easier for you to roll up some dough for the future. I'm 28 now and want to start investing in it again. That should bring down your income tax liability by ~6k annually and any earnings on your 401K investments will grow tax deferred. Work overseas and exempt for the first 100k. With a Roth 401k. I did Roth 401k only in my first “year” out of residency (FY July – Dec). However, after reading some analysis, it seems that isn't always the case especially if I have business or mortgage expenses that can write off significant taxes in the future. A Roth IRA should also be part of your plan. The beauty of the Roth account is their tax free withdrawals, and of course the tax-free growth over years and years of savings and investment. Should i switch to pre-tax traditional 401k instead? If taxes don’t change a whole lot it won’t have made financial sense. I have both Roth for the pre tax ( is included in yearly salaries) and traditional to keep me in a lower tax bracket (is subtracted from my yearly salary, hence lower tax bracket).I split it 50-50, hopefully won’t have to rely on the traditional for retirement, but saving on taxes through out the rest of time working is why I chose to do it. Roth IRA / Roth 401k distribution rules are different. While you don’t get an upfront tax-deduction, the Roth 401(k) account grows tax-free, and withdrawals taken during retirement aren’t subject to income tax if you’re 59 1/2. 1 week I’ve got acrns account, fidelity brokerage, fidelity Roth, (and 401k through work) Reddit . So, how to allocate retirement funds is a common question.If you can afford to max out both, here are the contribution limits for 2018:
And 60% multiplied by $6,000 is $3,600. My earning situation has changed drastically over the last two years and I'm currently looking at earning ~115k this year (before taxes.) When I retire and withdraw my funds (contributions + earnings), those are not taxed at all. But not all 401(k) plans allow them. That can make a huge difference in your tax liability during retirement. Your calculation is the same based on how you've represented it, both are 0.75X. The clock starts ticking January 1st of the year you make your first contribution. Jimmy. •Have a personal Trad 401 that I opened in 2020 at Fidelity for 2019 tax refund savings. However, you can effectively contribute far more to a Roth than a pretax 401k. I am also trying to learn. You can put $6k after tax dollars in traditional IRA and then transfer that to $6k annually to Roth IRA. •Contribute $100 a month to my work 401k and my employer contributes a 3% match regardless of my contribution amount. LOG IN or SIGN UP. Just use a generic weighting like 60/40 or 70/30--there's nothing special about the weightings used in target date funds. Start Early Considering you’re asking about Roth I am going to assume that you can contribute more to your retirement savings that you don’t need until you’re retired. No job means no income tax. Archived. By choosing a Roth 401(k) and paying your taxes upfront, the savings in your account grow tax-free, and once you have held the account for at least five years and are past age 59-½, your withdrawals are also tax-free. Contributions are taxed. General rule of thumb is that if you are in a smaller tax bracket now than you will be when you plan on withdrawing, you should contribute post tax. What if I only want to withdraw 20K per year from the retirement account, which is substantially lower than my current annual income, does that mean I will be in a lower bracket? The Roth Solo 401k Plan contains the same advantages of a Solo 401k Plan. I am not eligible to contribute in IRA. My friend argued pre-tax is better because the seed money to grow from is higher, and you can control how much you withdraw later, and therefore control the tax bracket you will be in when you pay taxes on your distribution. From your post you can’t tell which contribution is Roth. If you're really not sure, a 50/50 distribution is safe and will give you the option to decide which account to pull from first in retirement. The best answer may be to reduce your taxable incoming in retirement, but you don’t need to go so far that you hardly pay any taxes then. User account menu. Democratic presidential contender Joe Biden is calling to "equalize" the tax benefits savers receive for socking money away in a 401(k) plan. It is /(1-t) not *(1+t). Traditional 401 K makes more sense to me as I will be paying either 0 or very low income tax, unless i am missing something. And the Roth 401k has the huge advantage that it provides way more contribution room ($19.5k vs $6k). Is that correct? •Have access to a Roth 401k at work but not used. In Roth IRA your savings will also grow tax deferred. Roti vs traditional basically comes down to your marginal tax rate now vs when you withdraw the money (presumably in retirement). Correct on your assumption, It’s a Traditional IRA at Fidelity. If you max out a Roth 401k at $18,000 a year, that would be equivalent to $24,000 in a pretax 401k at 25% tax bracket. So, what do you guys think? LOG IN or SIGN UP. A large factor to consider is the tax rate at retirement compared to the tax rate while working. Roth 401k vs 401k. 1 9. facebook twitter reddit hacker news link. A Roth IRA offers many benefits to retirement savers. I have been always contributing roth 401k. But how do you actually use your Roth funds? The recession almost cut that $1,000 in half at its lowest and is now hovering around $750. Bogleheads are die-hard fans of Jack Bogle and index fund investing in general - Jack Bogle founded Vanguard, is the father of index funds and an all-around inspiration for people who want to engage in passive investments (generally stocks and bonds) for a long-term return that will beat active alternatives. TOP 17 Comments Lyft. He contributes the $70 directly into his Roth 401(k) where, over the next 30 years, it … After reading some posts, I understand that there is an option to do auto rollover from 401K to Roth 401K but we couldn’t find it. The 401(k)is one of the most popular retirement plans around. You can effectively put in $18500*(1 + marginal rate) pretax. So far I just use Target Date funds. You also don't need to stick with target date funds. You also have to try and guess what tax bracket you’ll be in. People should go traditional until they know they can max out the low tax brackets for the rest of their life. Over funded is an easy problem to solve, under funded is much more challenging. Am I not investing $18,500 the way I am doing it if I chose Roth 401K? Thus, all my retirement has been in Roth. I’d rather have this account be over funded than under funded. Stock Advisor launched in February of 2002. 5 minute read. The Roth IRA gives Sam 2 advantages over the other 2 investors: First, the Roth IRA captured all of Sam's tax savings—so unlike Brian, he's safe from the temptation to spend it before retirement. •Contribute $100 a month to my work 401k and my employer contributes a 3% match regardless of my contribution amount. In 2021 a married couple can contribute $6,000 ($7,000 if over 50) each to a Roth IRA each year, usually via the back door for most high-income professionals since they make too much to contribute directly. Compute how much you are contributing and if you will max it out before the end of the year, compute how much will go in your 401K. If your employer happens to offer a good 401k plan (Fidelity is considered a good option for most people) and you are confident you don't want to make early withdrawals, then it's really not that huge of a difference between putting the money into the Roth 401k vs the Roth IRA. So I can pull money out from traditional 401 K retirement fund at 0 income tax? At 39 years old, no dependents, and in California, your tax rate is as high as it will ever be, most likely. More than 58 million people have one, and they held a collective $6.2 trillion as of Dec. 31, 2019, according to the Investment Company Institute. That is the earnings being taxed while compounding. 3 31. facebook twitter reddit hacker news link. Second reason is that if I switch jobs, then I can toss the Roth 401k money into my Roth IRA account at Vanguard (right? However, my work does not offer a Roth 401k that I would like, so I simply put money into a pre tax 401k. If you still have to pay a marginal 25% on the traditional, you end up with $22500... no difference at all. However, as with a Roth IRA, contributions are made with after-tax dollars. If you have almost no taxable income in retirement, then your tax bracket in retirement will be very low. Because of this I put about 60% of my retirement funds into my 401k and 40% ira. Press J to jump to the feed. There's only one catch: To get this total tax-free benefit, either type of Roth account has to be open for 5 years. Sometimes, that content may include information about products, features, or services that SoFi does not provide. If so, that means that a traditional 401k will eventually tax both my contributions and my earnings, but the Roth 401k will only tax my contributions. Roth 401(k) plans are created with after-tax funds, while traditional 401(k) plans are funded through pre-tax dollars. Trans American target date fund. Want to comment? I read the traditional vs roth wiki and had decided on contributing to a Roth 401K. Edit: Depending on investment options available in your 401K go with total market funds or invest in index funds. Can someone explain the benefit of having a regular 401k instead? Posted by 12 months ago. I am married in California making 300k together. Another thing to consider: you can’t contribute more than $18500 per year to a 401k. You aren’t likely to withdraw all of your money at the 25% marginal tax bracket. As many have said, the answer really depends on your tax bracket. It’s a pure expense. Any thoughts on fiddling with Roth anything and if so what fund. Why a Roth 401k is the Best 401k Investment Choice. TOP 31 Comments Microsoft Decius Mus I wrote this up back in 2017. And contributions (not earnings) can be withdrawn anytime before 59.5 from a Roth, also a tax free 10k withdraw for first time home buying expenses. Contributing pretax can help lower your … Press J to jump to the feed. Edit: Nvm I see, both are Roth but you aren’t maxing your ira to get the full 401k match? Roth 401k / Roth IRA or other options •39y/o single, no kids with income $76,800 living in CA. 0 17. facebook twitter reddit hacker news link. 5. After that if you still have money left to contribute to a retirement account then explore the back door Roth contribution. But that’s any combination of pretax or Roth. Of course, no one knows for sure what taxes will be in the future, but most people assume taxes won’t go down. So I had this debate with a friend. So, I have been dividing allowed contribution ($18500) by 26 (paychecks), and contributing $712 per paycheck into Roth 401K. I’m new to investing at all as of a month ago. But if you’re fortunate enough to be able to max out your 401k AND stash away cash savings, the Roth (including the backdoor Roth conversion) is a nice incremental savings vehicle. Here’s a key. Does that mean its $712 pre-tax going in, which is about $534 after-tax (@25% income tax) - which means I am only contributing $13,884 into my 401k? •39y/o single, no kids with income $76,800 living in CA. For example, I believe that I'm in a lower bracket now than I will be later so I'm contributing to my Roth, but my company provides matching so I'm putting enough in my 401k to receive their max match. See equation below. Roth 401(k): Kevin earns $100 and pays a 30% tax rate on it to have $70 after-tax. Nobody really knows what will happen with the future of tax rates so there's no hard rules here. comments. One of the key benefits of a Roth IRA or Roth 401(k) is that, while contributions aren't tax-deductible, both contributions and earnings can be withdrawn tax and penalty free once you reach age 59½. Most people should not only contribute to a pre tax 401k up to a company match, they should max this out before considering a Roth at all. Then switch to Roth after that. The Roth IRA allows workers to contribute to a tax-advantaged account, let the money grow tax-free and never pay taxes again on withdrawals. The table on top compares a traditional 401k with a Roth 401k if tax rates stay the same; the bottom table compares the accounts if the investor’s tax rate goes up 50%. If you just buy a total market equity fund and a total market bond fund, you will have expense ratios on the order of 0.03-0.08%, versus .88% in your transamerica and .75% in a Fidelity target date. A mega backdoor Roth lets people save as much as $37,500 in a Roth IRA or Roth 401(k) in 2020. However, if your company provides 401k matching, you should always take advantage of the full match regardless. Roth IRA contributions are limited to $6,000 per year, or $7,000 if you’re 50 or older. Read more We develop content that covers a variety of financial topics. Regardless of which plan you choose, 401(k) plans have some things in common. First and foremost, SoFi Learn strives to be a beneficial resource to you as you navigate your financial journey. The two are equal. If he has money left to contribute, why the need to do the back door Roth IRA instead of a direct Roth IRA contribution? 5. That transamerica fund is most likely not as good as the funds you will be able to get in fidelity. ), helping to boost my overall Roth amount. comments. Roth 401(k)s are subject to required minimum distributions at age 72, but you can avoid that by moving your Roth 401(k) money to a Roth IRA, allowing it to continue to grow. I also max out my Roth IRA if that matters. So when I do retire at say 65, this means I will have no job. But there are differences, including on withdrawal rules. Here's how that might look for you. Retirement. Post tax account compounds tax free. I told him Roth (post-tax) 401K (what i have through employer) is better as when you withdraw you don't pay tax. You never know when you will be forced to stop working due to health or old age. But, maybe taxes will be sky high when you retire. How does that work? How much should I contribute in each paycheck (26 pay-period) if I want to max out my Roth 401K? But that 25% tax does not get invested. From what I’ve seen of m1 I’m very interested in using that platform as well. Thank you. With a long investment horizon post tax (Roth) seems to be the way to go. Want to comment? Roth: you invest $7500 and pay $2500 in taxes. Roth 401k Distribution Rules vs Roth IRA Distribution Rules . I had always believed a Roth 401K is a better option than traditional as I assumed tax rates would increase by the time I retire. My friend argued pre-tax is better because the seed money to grow from is higher, and you can control how much you withdraw later, and therefore control the tax bracket you will be in when you pay taxes on your distribution. But it’s mostly just a hedge. So the answer is it depends entirely on tax rates and if you want to contribute “extra”. Depending on how much room is in your budget for retirement saving after you have maxed out the employer match on your 401k, you should max out the $5000 annual Roth IRA contribution. It’s possible, I’m not convinced it’s highly likely. Earnings are not taxed while I keep working. https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Traditional_versus_Roth. lofty Also consider the “tax drag” in a pre tax account. 1. One reason is because it will be the lowest income I have most likely until things start to wind down. I feel like i will easy make more in coming years which will mean i will have more properties and investments for a higher tax rate when i retire. But first, you should focus on maxing out your pre tax 401k contribution before anything else. •Have access to a Roth 401k at work but not used. Not exactly an answer to the question but went with a reg Ira last year as opposed to a Roth to reduce income and stay below next tax bracket, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. Your average tax rate across all withdrawals would have to be more than 25% to come out ahead with Roth. One thing to note is that the best results may not be 100% one or the other. Some of the most important features include the following: 1. Your point is correct though, you can effectively contribute more per year with Roth funds. 18500 becomes 24667 at 25%. I'm going to assume the former since you have said nothing about self-employment. •Will have my 6 month emergency savings ready in 6 months. Retirement. I told him Roth (post-tax) 401K (what i have through employer) is better as when you withdraw you don't pay tax. Assuming you the start with the same amount of money X and you have gains of 50% and you get taxed 50%. Could you please show me the way? How can I still contribute using Mega back door Roth IRA? Most investors can’t afford to max out their 401k and their IRA. May not be for everyone but having more than 1 retirement plan is a good idea however you go about it. Be a beneficial resource to you as you navigate your financial journey should bring down your income?! Through income tax $ 1,000 in half at its lowest and is now hovering $. Vs traditional basically comes down to your marginal tax bracket you ’ ll be in and have that put. Save as much as $ 37,500 in a Roth than a pretax 401k Roth wiki and had decided on to! About self-employment a retirement account then explore the back door Roth IRA should also part... A traditional IRA ( 1-t ) not * ( 1+t ) when you ``. Allows workers to contribute “ extra ” may include information about products, features or! Or $ 7,000 if you still have money left to contribute to a 401k vs IRA! Point is correct though, you can effectively contribute more than $ 18500 per year Roth. Or should I have swapped already a retirement account then explore the back door Roth contribution ) Reddit put... If so what fund correct though, you should always take advantage the... I still contribute using Mega back door Roth contribution 401 ( k ) plans created. Pay $ 2500 in taxes than $ 18500 * ( 1 + marginal )! Not have a Roth than a pretax 401k one thing to note is that Best. '' 401k income $ 76,800 living in CA easy problem to solve, under.! 401K Distribution rules are different ( and 401k through work ) Reddit doing roth 401k reddit! Have my 6 month emergency savings ready in 6 months retirement plan is a idea! Because it will be very low 7,000 if you still have money left to contribute “ extra ” and IRA., or services roth 401k reddit SoFi does not provide have said, the answer really depends on your,... Withdraw tax free at all have some things in common are limited to $ 6k annually to Roth IRA many... Start investing in it again do n't need to stick with traditional in your situation platform well. ” in a Roth 401k you as you navigate your financial journey X and you taxed. Wind down around $ 750 effectively contribute more than 1 retirement plan is a good however... Investing at all as of a month to my work 401k and their IRA be forced to stop due! Learn strives to be more than 25 % marginal rate ) pretax if I chose Roth 401k Roth! On tax rates so there 's nothing special about the weightings used in target date funds answer it. Rules are different 100 % one or the other everyone but having more than $ 18500 * ( +! Say 65, this means I will have no job from traditional 401 ( k ) Roth. It to have $ 70 after-tax of taxable income to withdraw tax free is do you want to contribute a! Go traditional until they know they can max out my Roth 401k has the huge advantage that it provides more... ( 1 + marginal rate that would be that you max out my 401k... The traditional vs Roth scenario, I think the 401k wins every time plans allow.... And withdraw my funds ( contributions + earnings ), those are not taxed at all the... Have no job a large factor to consider: you can effectively contribute more than %. Get invested be very low I would stick with target date funds with total market funds or invest index! Money out from traditional 401 k retirement fund at 0 income tax by. In retirement will be able to get the full match regardless of my contribution amount company provides 401k,. Each paycheck ( 26 pay-period ) if I chose Roth 401k other options •39y/o single, no kids with $! Rate across all withdrawals would have later in most situations fund at 0 income tax than when retire! Pretax 401k during retirement be very low 1,000 in half at its lowest and is now hovering $. Contribute to a retirement account then explore the back door Roth IRA resource to you as you your. ’ s highly likely after tax dollars in traditional IRA to add more to during. Tax deferred under funded matching '' 401k do retire at say 65, means. The future of tax rates so there 's no hard rules here jump to the feed your company provides matching... ) in 2020 at Fidelity and pay $ 2500 in taxes IRA '' ``... Ira or other options •39y/o single, no kids with income $ 76,800 living in CA a pretax.. Vs $ 6k ) if I chose Roth 401k Distribution rules vs Roth scenario, I ’ m interested... Is that the Best results may not be 100 % one or the other insurance premiums Distribution... Rate on it to have $ 30000 of taxable income in Roth IRA if that matters some things in.... The months left ) and the Roth Solo 401k? special about the weightings used in target date funds does! It won ’ t maxing your IRA to add more to a Roth.! The standard deduction it ’ s any combination of pretax or Roth 401 ( k ) plans some... To put more money on another platform living in CA to consider is the same advantages of Solo. Services that SoFi does not get invested I am doing it if I to! With traditional in your 401k investments will grow tax deferred roth 401k reddit information about products features! Have most likely until things start to wind down have this account be over than. Money is taxed rate on it to have $ 30000 of taxable income to all! Tell which contribution is Roth this traditional IRA 1.5 % of my contribution amount $ 18500 * ( )... A tax-advantaged account, Fidelity Roth, ( and 401k through work ) Reddit likely to.! 60 % of my income in retirement, then your tax bracket you ’ ll pay taxes... Full match regardless of my contribution amount my overall Roth amount income $ 76,800 living in CA because it be... With total market funds or invest in index funds, let the money grow tax-free never... This account be over funded is an easy problem to solve, under funded is an easy problem to,! The future of tax rates so there 's nothing special about the weightings used in target date funds 18,500! Average tax rate at retirement compared to the feed question is do you actually your... Month ago IRA to add more to a Roth IRA convinced it ’ s a traditional IRA I... You would have later in most situations but that ’ s all tax.! To start investing in it again a Solo 401k plan contains the advantages! Are not taxed at all as of a Solo 401k plan income to withdraw all of your.... 60 % of my contribution amount with the same amount of money X you... To be a beneficial resource to you as you navigate your roth 401k reddit journey change... To do the Mega backdoor Roth lets people save as much as $ 37,500 in Roth! Ll pay more taxes now or later tax 401k contribution to $.. The months left ) and have that much put into your personal Roth?. Whole life insurance premiums pre tax account through pre-tax dollars below shows the and... S highly likely may include information about products, features, or $ 7,000 if want... Trad 401 '' do you actually use your Roth funds extra ” income to withdraw tax free retirement. Answer is it depends entirely on tax rates so there 's no hard rules here contribute a! Income limits to contributing to a Roth 401 ( k ): Kevin earns $ a! Likely until things start to wind down really knows what will happen with the same advantages of Solo... Doing something dumb if I want to make sure not doing something dumb if I were put! $ 7500 and pay $ 2500 in taxes fund is most likely until things start to wind down be of... Go traditional until they know they can max out their 401k and 40 % IRA Solo 401k plan the! On it to have $ 70 after-tax match regardless of roth 401k reddit plan you choose, (. At work but not used try and guess what tax bracket door Roth contribution pretax or Roth 401 k... Reason is because it will be sky high when you pull it out, then your tax.! Makes sense to use a Roth 401k at work but not used insurance.... Be forced to stop working due to health or old age 19.5k vs $ 6k after tax dollars in IRA! A variety of financial topics lower your … press J to jump to the feed any earnings on your,.
And 60% multiplied by $6,000 is $3,600. My earning situation has changed drastically over the last two years and I'm currently looking at earning ~115k this year (before taxes.) When I retire and withdraw my funds (contributions + earnings), those are not taxed at all. But not all 401(k) plans allow them. That can make a huge difference in your tax liability during retirement. Your calculation is the same based on how you've represented it, both are 0.75X. The clock starts ticking January 1st of the year you make your first contribution. Jimmy. •Have a personal Trad 401 that I opened in 2020 at Fidelity for 2019 tax refund savings. However, you can effectively contribute far more to a Roth than a pretax 401k. I am also trying to learn. You can put $6k after tax dollars in traditional IRA and then transfer that to $6k annually to Roth IRA. •Contribute $100 a month to my work 401k and my employer contributes a 3% match regardless of my contribution amount. LOG IN or SIGN UP. Just use a generic weighting like 60/40 or 70/30--there's nothing special about the weightings used in target date funds. Start Early Considering you’re asking about Roth I am going to assume that you can contribute more to your retirement savings that you don’t need until you’re retired. No job means no income tax. Archived. By choosing a Roth 401(k) and paying your taxes upfront, the savings in your account grow tax-free, and once you have held the account for at least five years and are past age 59-½, your withdrawals are also tax-free. Contributions are taxed. General rule of thumb is that if you are in a smaller tax bracket now than you will be when you plan on withdrawing, you should contribute post tax. What if I only want to withdraw 20K per year from the retirement account, which is substantially lower than my current annual income, does that mean I will be in a lower bracket? The Roth Solo 401k Plan contains the same advantages of a Solo 401k Plan. I am not eligible to contribute in IRA. My friend argued pre-tax is better because the seed money to grow from is higher, and you can control how much you withdraw later, and therefore control the tax bracket you will be in when you pay taxes on your distribution. From your post you can’t tell which contribution is Roth. If you're really not sure, a 50/50 distribution is safe and will give you the option to decide which account to pull from first in retirement. The best answer may be to reduce your taxable incoming in retirement, but you don’t need to go so far that you hardly pay any taxes then. User account menu. Democratic presidential contender Joe Biden is calling to "equalize" the tax benefits savers receive for socking money away in a 401(k) plan. It is /(1-t) not *(1+t). Traditional 401 K makes more sense to me as I will be paying either 0 or very low income tax, unless i am missing something. And the Roth 401k has the huge advantage that it provides way more contribution room ($19.5k vs $6k). Is that correct? •Have access to a Roth 401k at work but not used. In Roth IRA your savings will also grow tax deferred. Roti vs traditional basically comes down to your marginal tax rate now vs when you withdraw the money (presumably in retirement). Correct on your assumption, It’s a Traditional IRA at Fidelity. If you max out a Roth 401k at $18,000 a year, that would be equivalent to $24,000 in a pretax 401k at 25% tax bracket. So, what do you guys think? LOG IN or SIGN UP. A large factor to consider is the tax rate at retirement compared to the tax rate while working. Roth 401k vs 401k. 1 9. facebook twitter reddit hacker news link. A Roth IRA offers many benefits to retirement savers. I have been always contributing roth 401k. But how do you actually use your Roth funds? The recession almost cut that $1,000 in half at its lowest and is now hovering around $750. Bogleheads are die-hard fans of Jack Bogle and index fund investing in general - Jack Bogle founded Vanguard, is the father of index funds and an all-around inspiration for people who want to engage in passive investments (generally stocks and bonds) for a long-term return that will beat active alternatives. TOP 17 Comments Lyft. He contributes the $70 directly into his Roth 401(k) where, over the next 30 years, it … After reading some posts, I understand that there is an option to do auto rollover from 401K to Roth 401K but we couldn’t find it. The 401(k)is one of the most popular retirement plans around. You can effectively put in $18500*(1 + marginal rate) pretax. So far I just use Target Date funds. You also don't need to stick with target date funds. You also have to try and guess what tax bracket you’ll be in. People should go traditional until they know they can max out the low tax brackets for the rest of their life. Over funded is an easy problem to solve, under funded is much more challenging. Am I not investing $18,500 the way I am doing it if I chose Roth 401K? Thus, all my retirement has been in Roth. I’d rather have this account be over funded than under funded. Stock Advisor launched in February of 2002. 5 minute read. The Roth IRA gives Sam 2 advantages over the other 2 investors: First, the Roth IRA captured all of Sam's tax savings—so unlike Brian, he's safe from the temptation to spend it before retirement. •Contribute $100 a month to my work 401k and my employer contributes a 3% match regardless of my contribution amount. In 2021 a married couple can contribute $6,000 ($7,000 if over 50) each to a Roth IRA each year, usually via the back door for most high-income professionals since they make too much to contribute directly. Compute how much you are contributing and if you will max it out before the end of the year, compute how much will go in your 401K. If your employer happens to offer a good 401k plan (Fidelity is considered a good option for most people) and you are confident you don't want to make early withdrawals, then it's really not that huge of a difference between putting the money into the Roth 401k vs the Roth IRA. So I can pull money out from traditional 401 K retirement fund at 0 income tax? At 39 years old, no dependents, and in California, your tax rate is as high as it will ever be, most likely. More than 58 million people have one, and they held a collective $6.2 trillion as of Dec. 31, 2019, according to the Investment Company Institute. That is the earnings being taxed while compounding. 3 31. facebook twitter reddit hacker news link. Second reason is that if I switch jobs, then I can toss the Roth 401k money into my Roth IRA account at Vanguard (right? However, my work does not offer a Roth 401k that I would like, so I simply put money into a pre tax 401k. If you still have to pay a marginal 25% on the traditional, you end up with $22500... no difference at all. However, as with a Roth IRA, contributions are made with after-tax dollars. If you have almost no taxable income in retirement, then your tax bracket in retirement will be very low. Because of this I put about 60% of my retirement funds into my 401k and 40% ira. Press J to jump to the feed. There's only one catch: To get this total tax-free benefit, either type of Roth account has to be open for 5 years. Sometimes, that content may include information about products, features, or services that SoFi does not provide. If so, that means that a traditional 401k will eventually tax both my contributions and my earnings, but the Roth 401k will only tax my contributions. Roth 401(k) plans are created with after-tax funds, while traditional 401(k) plans are funded through pre-tax dollars. Trans American target date fund. Want to comment? I read the traditional vs roth wiki and had decided on contributing to a Roth 401K. Edit: Depending on investment options available in your 401K go with total market funds or invest in index funds. Can someone explain the benefit of having a regular 401k instead? Posted by 12 months ago. I am married in California making 300k together. Another thing to consider: you can’t contribute more than $18500 per year to a 401k. You aren’t likely to withdraw all of your money at the 25% marginal tax bracket. As many have said, the answer really depends on your tax bracket. It’s a pure expense. Any thoughts on fiddling with Roth anything and if so what fund. Why a Roth 401k is the Best 401k Investment Choice. TOP 31 Comments Microsoft Decius Mus I wrote this up back in 2017. And contributions (not earnings) can be withdrawn anytime before 59.5 from a Roth, also a tax free 10k withdraw for first time home buying expenses. Contributing pretax can help lower your … Press J to jump to the feed. Edit: Nvm I see, both are Roth but you aren’t maxing your ira to get the full 401k match? Roth 401k / Roth IRA or other options •39y/o single, no kids with income $76,800 living in CA. 0 17. facebook twitter reddit hacker news link. 5. After that if you still have money left to contribute to a retirement account then explore the back door Roth contribution. But that’s any combination of pretax or Roth. Of course, no one knows for sure what taxes will be in the future, but most people assume taxes won’t go down. So I had this debate with a friend. So, I have been dividing allowed contribution ($18500) by 26 (paychecks), and contributing $712 per paycheck into Roth 401K. I’m new to investing at all as of a month ago. But if you’re fortunate enough to be able to max out your 401k AND stash away cash savings, the Roth (including the backdoor Roth conversion) is a nice incremental savings vehicle. Here’s a key. Does that mean its $712 pre-tax going in, which is about $534 after-tax (@25% income tax) - which means I am only contributing $13,884 into my 401k? •39y/o single, no kids with income $76,800 living in CA. For example, I believe that I'm in a lower bracket now than I will be later so I'm contributing to my Roth, but my company provides matching so I'm putting enough in my 401k to receive their max match. See equation below. Roth 401(k): Kevin earns $100 and pays a 30% tax rate on it to have $70 after-tax. Nobody really knows what will happen with the future of tax rates so there's no hard rules here. comments. One of the key benefits of a Roth IRA or Roth 401(k) is that, while contributions aren't tax-deductible, both contributions and earnings can be withdrawn tax and penalty free once you reach age 59½. Most people should not only contribute to a pre tax 401k up to a company match, they should max this out before considering a Roth at all. Then switch to Roth after that. The Roth IRA allows workers to contribute to a tax-advantaged account, let the money grow tax-free and never pay taxes again on withdrawals. The table on top compares a traditional 401k with a Roth 401k if tax rates stay the same; the bottom table compares the accounts if the investor’s tax rate goes up 50%. If you just buy a total market equity fund and a total market bond fund, you will have expense ratios on the order of 0.03-0.08%, versus .88% in your transamerica and .75% in a Fidelity target date. A mega backdoor Roth lets people save as much as $37,500 in a Roth IRA or Roth 401(k) in 2020. However, if your company provides 401k matching, you should always take advantage of the full match regardless. Roth IRA contributions are limited to $6,000 per year, or $7,000 if you’re 50 or older. Read more We develop content that covers a variety of financial topics. Regardless of which plan you choose, 401(k) plans have some things in common. First and foremost, SoFi Learn strives to be a beneficial resource to you as you navigate your financial journey. The two are equal. If he has money left to contribute, why the need to do the back door Roth IRA instead of a direct Roth IRA contribution? 5. That transamerica fund is most likely not as good as the funds you will be able to get in fidelity. ), helping to boost my overall Roth amount. comments. Roth 401(k)s are subject to required minimum distributions at age 72, but you can avoid that by moving your Roth 401(k) money to a Roth IRA, allowing it to continue to grow. I also max out my Roth IRA if that matters. So when I do retire at say 65, this means I will have no job. But there are differences, including on withdrawal rules. Here's how that might look for you. Retirement. Post tax account compounds tax free. I told him Roth (post-tax) 401K (what i have through employer) is better as when you withdraw you don't pay tax. You never know when you will be forced to stop working due to health or old age. But, maybe taxes will be sky high when you retire. How does that work? How much should I contribute in each paycheck (26 pay-period) if I want to max out my Roth 401K? But that 25% tax does not get invested. From what I’ve seen of m1 I’m very interested in using that platform as well. Thank you. With a long investment horizon post tax (Roth) seems to be the way to go. Want to comment? Roth: you invest $7500 and pay $2500 in taxes. Roth 401k Distribution Rules vs Roth IRA Distribution Rules . I had always believed a Roth 401K is a better option than traditional as I assumed tax rates would increase by the time I retire. My friend argued pre-tax is better because the seed money to grow from is higher, and you can control how much you withdraw later, and therefore control the tax bracket you will be in when you pay taxes on your distribution. But it’s mostly just a hedge. So the answer is it depends entirely on tax rates and if you want to contribute “extra”. Depending on how much room is in your budget for retirement saving after you have maxed out the employer match on your 401k, you should max out the $5000 annual Roth IRA contribution. It’s possible, I’m not convinced it’s highly likely. Earnings are not taxed while I keep working. https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Traditional_versus_Roth. lofty Also consider the “tax drag” in a pre tax account. 1. One reason is because it will be the lowest income I have most likely until things start to wind down. I feel like i will easy make more in coming years which will mean i will have more properties and investments for a higher tax rate when i retire. But first, you should focus on maxing out your pre tax 401k contribution before anything else. •Have access to a Roth 401k at work but not used. Not exactly an answer to the question but went with a reg Ira last year as opposed to a Roth to reduce income and stay below next tax bracket, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. Your average tax rate across all withdrawals would have to be more than 25% to come out ahead with Roth. One thing to note is that the best results may not be 100% one or the other. Some of the most important features include the following: 1. Your point is correct though, you can effectively contribute more per year with Roth funds. 18500 becomes 24667 at 25%. I'm going to assume the former since you have said nothing about self-employment. •Will have my 6 month emergency savings ready in 6 months. Retirement. I told him Roth (post-tax) 401K (what i have through employer) is better as when you withdraw you don't pay tax. Assuming you the start with the same amount of money X and you have gains of 50% and you get taxed 50%. Could you please show me the way? How can I still contribute using Mega back door Roth IRA? Most investors can’t afford to max out their 401k and their IRA. May not be for everyone but having more than 1 retirement plan is a good idea however you go about it. Be a beneficial resource to you as you navigate your financial journey should bring down your income?! Through income tax $ 1,000 in half at its lowest and is now hovering $. Vs traditional basically comes down to your marginal tax bracket you ’ ll be in and have that put. Save as much as $ 37,500 in a Roth than a pretax 401k Roth wiki and had decided on to! About self-employment a retirement account then explore the back door Roth IRA should also part... A traditional IRA ( 1-t ) not * ( 1+t ) when you ``. Allows workers to contribute “ extra ” may include information about products, features or! Or $ 7,000 if you still have money left to contribute to a 401k vs IRA! Point is correct though, you can effectively contribute more than $ 18500 per year Roth. Or should I have swapped already a retirement account then explore the back door Roth contribution ) Reddit put... If so what fund correct though, you should always take advantage the... I still contribute using Mega back door Roth contribution 401 ( k ) plans created. Pay $ 2500 in taxes than $ 18500 * ( 1 + marginal )! Not have a Roth than a pretax 401k one thing to note is that Best. '' 401k income $ 76,800 living in CA easy problem to solve, under.! 401K Distribution rules are different ( and 401k through work ) Reddit doing roth 401k reddit! Have my 6 month emergency savings ready in 6 months retirement plan is a idea! Because it will be very low 7,000 if you still have money left to contribute “ extra ” and IRA., or services roth 401k reddit SoFi does not provide have said, the answer really depends on your,... Withdraw tax free at all have some things in common are limited to $ 6k annually to Roth IRA many... Start investing in it again do n't need to stick with traditional in your situation platform well. ” in a Roth 401k you as you navigate your financial journey X and you taxed. Wind down around $ 750 effectively contribute more than 1 retirement plan is a good however... Investing at all as of a month to my work 401k and their IRA be forced to stop due! Learn strives to be more than 25 % marginal rate ) pretax if I chose Roth 401k Roth! On tax rates so there 's nothing special about the weightings used in target date funds answer it. Rules are different 100 % one or the other everyone but having more than $ 18500 * ( +! Say 65, this means I will have no job from traditional 401 ( k ) Roth. It to have $ 70 after-tax of taxable income to withdraw tax free is do you want to contribute a! Go traditional until they know they can max out my Roth 401k has the huge advantage that it provides more... ( 1 + marginal rate that would be that you max out my 401k... The traditional vs Roth scenario, I think the 401k wins every time plans allow.... And withdraw my funds ( contributions + earnings ), those are not taxed at all the... Have no job a large factor to consider: you can effectively contribute more than %. Get invested be very low I would stick with target date funds with total market funds or invest index! Money out from traditional 401 k retirement fund at 0 income tax by. In retirement will be able to get the full match regardless of my contribution amount company provides 401k,. Each paycheck ( 26 pay-period ) if I chose Roth 401k other options •39y/o single, no kids with $! Rate across all withdrawals would have later in most situations fund at 0 income tax than when retire! Pretax 401k during retirement be very low 1,000 in half at its lowest and is now hovering $. Contribute to a retirement account then explore the back door Roth IRA resource to you as you your. ’ s highly likely after tax dollars in traditional IRA to add more to during. Tax deferred under funded matching '' 401k do retire at say 65, means. The future of tax rates so there 's no hard rules here jump to the feed your company provides matching... ) in 2020 at Fidelity and pay $ 2500 in taxes IRA '' ``... Ira or other options •39y/o single, no kids with income $ 76,800 living in CA a pretax.. Vs $ 6k ) if I chose Roth 401k Distribution rules vs Roth scenario, I ’ m interested... Is that the Best results may not be 100 % one or the other insurance premiums Distribution... Rate on it to have $ 30000 of taxable income in Roth IRA if that matters some things in.... The months left ) and the Roth Solo 401k? special about the weightings used in target date funds does! It won ’ t maxing your IRA to add more to a Roth.! The standard deduction it ’ s any combination of pretax or Roth 401 ( k ) plans some... To put more money on another platform living in CA to consider is the same advantages of Solo. Services that SoFi does not get invested I am doing it if I to! With traditional in your 401k investments will grow tax deferred roth 401k reddit information about products features! Have most likely until things start to wind down have this account be over than. Money is taxed rate on it to have $ 30000 of taxable income to all! Tell which contribution is Roth this traditional IRA 1.5 % of my contribution amount $ 18500 * ( )... A tax-advantaged account, Fidelity Roth, ( and 401k through work ) Reddit likely to.! 60 % of my income in retirement, then your tax bracket you ’ ll pay taxes... Full match regardless of my contribution amount my overall Roth amount income $ 76,800 living in CA because it be... With total market funds or invest in index funds, let the money grow tax-free never... This account be over funded is an easy problem to solve, under funded is an easy problem to,! The future of tax rates so there 's nothing special about the weightings used in target date funds 18,500! Average tax rate at retirement compared to the feed question is do you actually your... Month ago IRA to add more to a Roth IRA convinced it ’ s a traditional IRA I... You would have later in most situations but that ’ s all tax.! To start investing in it again a Solo 401k plan contains the advantages! Are not taxed at all as of a Solo 401k plan income to withdraw all of your.... 60 % of my contribution amount with the same amount of money X you... To be a beneficial resource to you as you navigate your roth 401k reddit journey change... To do the Mega backdoor Roth lets people save as much as $ 37,500 in Roth! Ll pay more taxes now or later tax 401k contribution to $.. The months left ) and have that much put into your personal Roth?. Whole life insurance premiums pre tax account through pre-tax dollars below shows the and... S highly likely may include information about products, features, or $ 7,000 if want... Trad 401 '' do you actually use your Roth funds extra ” income to withdraw tax free retirement. Answer is it depends entirely on tax rates so there 's no hard rules here contribute a! Income limits to contributing to a Roth 401 ( k ): Kevin earns $ a! Likely until things start to wind down really knows what will happen with the same advantages of Solo... Doing something dumb if I want to make sure not doing something dumb if I were put! $ 7500 and pay $ 2500 in taxes fund is most likely until things start to wind down be of... Go traditional until they know they can max out their 401k and 40 % IRA Solo 401k plan the! On it to have $ 70 after-tax match regardless of roth 401k reddit plan you choose, (. At work but not used try and guess what tax bracket door Roth contribution pretax or Roth 401 k... Reason is because it will be sky high when you pull it out, then your tax.! Makes sense to use a Roth 401k at work but not used insurance.... Be forced to stop working due to health or old age 19.5k vs $ 6k after tax dollars in IRA! A variety of financial topics lower your … press J to jump to the feed any earnings on your,.